I'd suggest a BJ if you're not that into PvP'ing--you could always restat into a YJ when you're done leveling and wanna go PvP. I know I'd make a BJ (and did although I also made a BP before) since I don't really care much for PvP either.
BP's do pretty sad damage imo if you don't have great equipment--but from what you've posted it sounds like you've made a BJ before?
If that's the case maybe you should try BPs--they've always been one of my favorite classes
